Implementing Strategy:A Balancing Act
Strategies often fail in organisations because they are not successfully converted into actions that employees can understand and employ in their everyday work. The measures used to determine whether a strategy is working or not are usually far removed from what employees believe they can influence.
Measurements of strategy implementation are usually restricted to the financial level. Measures remain at a high level and are not at a level disaggregated enough for employees to see for themselves whether they are contributing to the strategy or not.
In the early 1990's Robert Kaplan and David Norton developed an approach, the balanced scorecard', to provide a balanced picture of what is happening throughout the organisation, not just one facet of it. Additionally, they sought to provide measures which are meaningful to those responsible for the work and visibly related to the strategy of an organisation.
The balanced scorecard concentrates on measures in four strategic areas; finance, customers, internal business processes and innovation. The method requires organisations to come up with goals and measures for each strategic area. The following goals and measures are regularly applied from each perspective.
From the financial perspective the goals tend to be about either survival or prosperity. The measures tend to be about revenue growth, cash flow, return on capital, cost reduction, project profitability and performance reliability.
From the customer perspective the goals tend to be about the customer experience, customer acquisition and retention and customer profitability. The measures tend to be about market share, transaction cost ratios, customer satisfaction and loyalty, supplier relationships and key account relationships.
From the business process perspective the goals tend to be about business processes, core competencies and critical technologies. The measures tend to be about efficiency measures for operational processes, cycle times, unit costs, defect rates and project effectiveness.
From the learning and innovation perspective the goals tend to be about continuous improvement and new product development. The measures tend to be about new idea generation, competency levels, employee satisfaction, staff attitude and retention.
Creating a balanced scorecard requires the input of all senior managers. A method for developing a balanced scorecard involves a series of interviews and three workshops.
The first step is to define the scope for which the balanced scorecard will be created. In large organisations it is important at this stage to ensure that the scope is wide enough to avoid creation of silos without making the exercise too difficult in sheer breadth of activities. Having determined the scope, the senior management team is interviewed individually for their view of the strategic direction and initial thoughts on the balanced scorecard components.
The first workshop with the senior management team sets out to determine for each of the four perspectives what would be different if the vision of the organisation was achieved, what critical factors would enable the vision to be achieved and what measures for each critical factor would show that the vision was being achieved.
After consolidating the findings of the workshop a second set of interviews is undertaken to refine the emerging scorecard.
The second workshop sets out to debate a proposed scorecard and link ongoing change programmes to the measures and setting targets for improvement for each of the measures. The workshop also should begin to develop a communication strategy and an outline of the implementation processes.
The third workshop develops final consensus on the vision/goals, measures and targets and develops an implementation programme to communicate the scorecard to employees, integrate the scorecard into management philosophy and develop an information system to support it.
The second last phase is implementation. An implementation team is given the objective of communicating the what, why, where and who of the scorecard and developing the how by linking databases and information support systems to the scorecard. The end product should be a management information system linking strategy to shop floor activity.
The last phase is to regularly review the scorecard for relevance as the environment in which organisations operate changes. Achievement of intermediate goals also opens up new possibilities for the vision of the organisation.
A common mistake to be avoided in developing a balanced scorecard is getting lost in the minutiae of too many detailed measures. Be sure that the measures do genuinely relate to the strategic goals of the organisation. Another common mistake is to define the scope of activities too narrowly resulting in a silo approach to executing strategy, defeating the initial purpose of the scorecard.
Strategic planning is important for organisations to succeed but is not enough. They need to ensure the strategy is understood by employees and measured in a manner which is relevant to them. Building a balanced scorecard rather than one built solely on financial metrics will provide employees with a sense of how they contribute to the strategy.
Kevin Dwyer is Director of Change Factory. Change Factory helps organisations who do do not like their business outcomes to get better outcomes by changing people's behaviour. Businesses we help have greater clarity of purpose and ability to achieve their desired business outcomes. To learn more visit http://www.changefactory.com.au or email kevin.dwyer@changefactory.com.au
To see more articles visit http://www.changefactory.com.au
Implementing TQM - Who Should Drive TQM Initiative
Total Quality Management, in short commonly called "TQM", has been in the business jargon for many many years. There has been...
Project Manager: Roles and Skills
Generally, the project manager is responsible for the overall accomplishment of the project, and accountable for ensuring obj...
Six Sigma for Small Business
It is not surprising that some people may perceive Six Sigma as being only for large corporations. Major corporations such as...
Project Management
Project management is actually a carefully planned and organized effort which is set to accomplish a particular project in a ...
Data Quality Management 101 - The Basics
What is Data Quality Management?
Data quality management is the process of tracking and analyzing the data in customer and b...
The Six Sigma Mis-Implementation: How to Know if You’re a Victim, Before It’s Too Late!
Though the benefits of implementing the Six Sigma strategy to a businesss processes can lead to far greater successes that co...
Communications And Six Sigma
Implementing new work techniques, strategies, or management systems in business organizations is often a daunting task for ma...
Six Sigma For Small Businesses
Six Sigma is a series of systems that focus on implementing quality measurement strategies based on data and statistical anal...
Business Process Management
Business Processes are a group of activities which are recurring in nature and contribute significantly to the growth and dev...
Homeschooling and Working From Home
Many work at home moms homeschool their children, as do many mothers who work outside the home both full time and part time. ...
Six Sigma And Healthcare
Six Sigma methodologies aim at improving overall quality by eliminating defects and achieving near perfection by restricting ...
Creativity Management: The Best Organizational Structure
A firm's organisational structure is the result of many things history, strategy, value chain, product line, competition etc...
5 Tips for Working "In" and "On" Your Business…At the Same Time
Congratulations! You just landed a big new contract. Now for the bad news. Who will run your company while youre buried under...
Health Benefits With Delicious Hot Cocoa Made With Pure Essential Oils
Nourish Body and Soul with this Hot Cocoa recipe made with Pure Essential Oils!HOT COCOA FLAVORED WITH PURE ESSENTIAL OILS - ...
The Money Is In The List
A very successful Internet marketer once said that if he lost everything the only thing he would need to start again was his ...
5 Steps To Effective Customer Loyalty Programs
Increasingly organizations are becoming dissatisfied with their customer satisfaction surveys and turning instead to designin...
Be Your Own Boss; Lay the Foundation for a Prosperous Business with New Business Loans
We all like to have full control on the steering of our lives. We want to be our own bosses. Often, one feels bored and fed u...
Implementing A Home School Course
The inconsistencies surrounding educational programs throughout the nation, in combination with the educational needs of part...
Virtual Homeschooling - Getting Started with Online Curriculum for K-12 Students
Here we cover the Beginners Guide to using online curriculum and retain your initial excitement for this novel approach to le...
Quick Acne Treatments Exposed: The Truth Behind Miracle Acne Cures
Can acne be cured quickly and without effort? Is there really a revolutionary acne treatment overlooked by the medical establ...